Upon chatting with an Amazon Associate to understand why this occurred, I was told this was a "technical glitch in the system. The Amazon Associate said they had gone ahead and marked my return as complete at the Amazon Fulfillment center.
This is a reminder to return the item below. We’ve issued your refund in advance, but still expect to receive the return. Send the item back by Tue, Jan 18 to avoid being charged again. Please click ‘View return and refund status’ to access your return label.
Your original payment method will be charged $32.91 if you don’t send the item back by Tue, Jan 18.
This email was sent from a notification-only address that cannot accept incoming email. Please do not reply to this message.